Someone betrayed the Lusitania to the Germans. They both have the signature feel of their writer and director, Rian Johnson. He is torn between two families, not knowing which is his past and which should be his present. As historical fictionThe Glass Ocean works beautifully. Rian Johnson's Primal Scream. The book had three amazing narrators who gave the perfect unique voice to each of these characters. The movie ends with Blanc and Helen waiting for the police boats, with the world-class detective triumphant in yet another layered and mysterious case. I also felt there was too much emotion and tension to be resolved in the short time span we get at sea. It's the beginning of a universe, but it could also be the beginning of an all-out war, and of a society in which every crowd could hold several individuals capable of reducing the people around them to dust. I was never confused and I think this was helped by the fact that I listen to this on audio. And the rest of the guests have ties to Klear as well. With the battle between Jolyne Cujoh and . Part of what makes this so much fun is the way that in both time periods both end up as just the kind of spy thriller that Robert Langford used to write. But the best part comes last. A man withdissociative identity disorder, Crumb lives with more than 20 personalities including one dubbed "The Beast," imbued with superhuman strength and a desire to rid the world of "impure" individuals who've never known suffering. 1. Now, as Andis sister points out, he will be. Make a prediction. CNN anchor Jake Tapper and cellist Yo-Yo Ma appear early on in the movie. Also Read: A Glass Onion Spoiler Q&A With Rian Johnson. Miles also used his influence to strongarm his friends into supporting a revolutionary new form of hydrogen fuel called Klear that he plans to launch as part of Alpha's newest business venture. By Lauren O'Callaghan. DNFed at 45%; this wasnt awful, but the writing is very low-quality and the narrative very unengaging. He even brags, "I want to be mentioned in the same breath as the Mona Lisa." So, when Sam tells Vincent that he doesnt know whether his stay is permanent, he is just being honest about the situation. This fiery climax comes after a second half that has already entirely upended the film's . This talks about the mystery th. King's book and the TV miniseries based on it are about how a community interacts in isolation when catastrophe strikes, and the normal rules and systems are stripped away. He has approximate knowledge of many things, all of them related to various forms of pop culture. Someone wanted to secure it for the British. He is seemingly poisoned. As they settle in, Miles shows them his Glass Onion a glass house located at the center of the island. Beatrix Williams, Karen White, and Lauren Willig's collaboration was flawless, beautiful, and riveting. The results would be catastrophic for everyone as they all backed up Miles' version of events in court that he came up with the initial idea that launched Alpha. The very end to their story fits the romance bill although it had me rolling my eyes at John for a moment. Despite her happiness to have her son back, Beth can see that Sam is not happy. Miles didnt take the bait though, swiftly killing him as well by putting pineapple juice in his glass and handing it to Duke, who was deathly allergic to the fruit. Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery will be available to stream on Netflix on December 23. Of course, Helen could get in some trouble too given the huge criminal damage that she caused, but we're choosing to believe that doesn't happen. Truly wonderful. Whiskey runs into the room crying, claiming Andi is the murderer. I wasn't satisfied with Immanence (2022), due to the abrupt ending, with no resolution. As with the previous book by the Team W, The Forgotten Room, the story of The Glass Ocean slips from character to character from woman to woman as the reader experiences each perspective and follows the treasure hunt as all three of the stories finally come together. If you've written a review for a romance that you think might interest the community or you'd like to rant and/or squee about a book, and you haven't published it elsewhere, please email Sarah. Will she be killed? Chief among them is Andi Brand (Janelle Mone), Miles' former business partner who wound up muscled out of their company. Among the guests is renowned detective Benoit Blanc (Daniel Craig) - but Miles never sent him an invitation. Given Miles knew Andi was dead when his guests received their invitations, some viewers might be wondering why he bothered to send one to her. There are a lot of things to lose in this world, but the loss of one's child brings unparalleled pain. So what is the next city? As of December 1st . Someone smuggled a critical munitions formula on board the ship. The 1915 story includes Caroline Hochstetter who is married to Gilbert. It didnt help I guess that I had just watched Titanic with my granddaughter for about the 10th time. When Derol was first introduced in the movie, we did wonder if he could play a bigger role in the plot. Her partner has promised that if they can pull off this one last heist aboard the Lusitania, theyll finally leave the game behind. Shed written the idea on a napkin at their local bar the Glass Onion, but the evidence had been lost. Her mother is suffering from dementia and her nursing home bills are piling up, making it urgent that Sarah find a topic that will earn her a great advance. However, just like the original Knives Out, there are no more Easter eggs hidden at the end. In 2021, Arctic sea ice was 12th lowest on record. Amanda reveals that Minos kidnapped her daughter, Sonya, and forced her to become their architect. As the footage of what happened at the institution makes it way out into the world, Mrs. Price channeling her son's obsession with comics declares it to be the "beginning of a universe," as presumably special people everywhere are realizing their potential. Benoit Blanc, that slippery southern detective played by Daniel Craig, is back in "Glass Onion," Rian Johnson's follow-up to "Knives . Tess desperately wants to believe that, but Tess has the uneasy feeling theres something about this job that isnt as it seems. Starring Michelle Pfeiffer in the lead role, it traces the journey of a family that goes to hell and back when its young member is lost. But much like its namesake, Glass Onion contains more than a few layers when it comes to its central mystery, and Johnson takes his time unraveling it all, leading to a stunning conclusion. While there, he poisoned Andi. You have to know there will be sadness. Questions drive the story right to the very end. Speaking to Digital Spy (opens in new tab), Johnson said of Knives Out 3: "The key is landing on something that first of all feels different than the first two and also feels like the only reason for us to keep making these is if we're excited about making them. Its only for a few minutes that she leaves them out of her sight, but that is enough for a tragedy to occur. After learning about Andis death thanks to a Google alert, he pieced everything together and tried to manipulate Miles into allowing him a spot on Alphas news network. Weaving between two timelines, THE GLASS OCEAN takes us from 1915 on board the RMS Lusitania to 2013, in Devon, England. The big misdirect. Mom used to tell this story about the dinner parties they once had, before Dad left, and how I used to peek through the bannister when I was supposed to be sleeping and watch the guests, and how, in the morning, I would bombard her with questions about them, who was married to whom, who did what for a living, who came from where and had how many siblings. We also learn that Ben is alive and trapped inside a glass cage connected to . Even the actual murderer Miles doesnt mention her being there. What she discovers there could change history. Tess Fairweather is also on the Lusitania, along with her sister Ginny. The Glass Onion ending explained. Rating: Weak (2- out of 3 points). Naturally, Bill arrives at around the same time, so at least The Mosquito Coast season 1, episode 7 actually starts to feel like a finale here. She suspects her husband has business dealings that involve him in the war, but she doesnt know for which side. Caroline and Tess are two women from very different circumstances who find themselves onboard the Lusitania in May of 1915. Despite the dangers of travelling by sea during war time, Caroline hopes the trip on the Lusitania will help them reconnect. It is full of mystery and keeps the reader guessing and wondering who can be trusted and who's on what side. So will the organization keep to the shadows and try not to make the trail of bodies leading to them even bigger? Heres what I thought. Gilbert is insistent that they bring along a rare piece of music he bought for Caroline as a wedding gift to sell to a prospective buyer in London. Will the United States government look into it? It is heart-breaking and soul-wrecking and difficult, if somehow not impossible, to cope with. But all the characters you are primarily involved with come out on top, for the most part. . 4 min read. I thought it was interesting that they chose a traumatic historical event as an anchor point, because as readers we know it will end tragically which further builds . To be honest, this was the only part that I disliked. The business about the rare piece of music put me in mind of Harry Widener (namesake of Harvards library) returning from England to America with a newly acquired copy of Bacons Essays (pub. Before we get to the island, it's imperative we introduce the players in this macabre tale. Blanc deduces that someone intends to have Miles killed and as the film progresses, everyone is revealed to have plenty of motives to want their so-called friend dead. Im an Entertainment Writer here at GamesRadar+, covering TV and film for the Total Film and SFX sections online. The painting is lost in the fire, and Helen points out to Miles that he did get his wish - just not in the way he wanted. I tried to divine his life, his history, the peculiar secrets hidden in his past. Its the modern bit where the plucky American raids the family records of the British guyI gave up on Willigs pink carnation series because I was so annoyed with the present day cutesy banter of the central couple. The end left me thinking if this was a good ending or a bad ending for both the Joestars and Pucci. I found that to be true here also. No, theres no post-credits scene at the end of Glass Onion. By ending with the possibility of new heroes, new villains, and a new mission, Glass provides a clear expression of the evolution of comic book storytelling, showcasing the shift from superheroes . 1. While any kind of movement or danger will encase the painting in an impenetrable box, Miles has also shown off that he had a workaround installed. Sarah needs an idea soon. Of course, with the trio locked up, setting the wheels in motion for his latest scheme isn't simple but once they're all in the same building, being treated for apparent delusions of grandeur, Price's devious intellect is more than enough to lay the groundwork for an escape that will lead to the conflict Mr. Glass has been hoping to spark all along. He's obviously super fucking old, but he's still around. "The Glass Hotel" by Emily St. John Mandel Photo: Knopf "The Glass Hotel," Emily St. John Mandel's masterful fifth novel, starts in motion. Though her mission to maintain balance was quite clear, Dr. Staple did still seem to have some degree of compassion and even respect for her patients, and she really seemed to hope she could convince them they were delusional rather than put them down. Her encounter gave her the courage to report her uncle for his repeated abuse, and he went to jail while she was placed in a loving foster home. Spare by Prince Harry, with Melissa Blue, 548. Left with no other option, she sets about destroying his priceless sculptures, before using Klear to create a bomb that destroys the Glass Onion and the Mona Lisa with it. I found I really enjoyed Carolines and Sarahs story. Read our spoiler-free review here. Make sure to check out the podcast, too. Have you seen our Books on Sale collection? The film opens with Benoit Blanc (Daniel . She tries to use the procedure on Elijah, but he dupes her, and then later she assures her colleagues she will "use the machine" on anyone she is unable to convince they're delusional. It seems like he disappeared into thin air, and finally, Beth decides its time to accept the fact that he is not coming back. David's death is particularly brutal and merciless, and now it's on tape for the world to see. To say that the three W writers are some of my favorites is an understatement. In fact, he orchestrated the horrific events that led to his discovery of Dunn in the first place, and sees himself as the perfectly opposed villain to Dunn's hero. While Carolines and Tess stories are part of that fateful voyage, Sarahs is the story of the aftermath nearly 100 years in the aftermath. Duke (Buatista), the brawny YouTube star with the cutie pie girlfriend (Madelyn Cline), dies. And I used to think this story of hers was true. The evidence that she found was a napkin featuring the sketches that launched their company Alpha, which she came up with. Oceans are the storehouses of water nature uses to run the water cycle. Even her agent is losing patience with her. Rian Johnson wants to delight and make you laugh, and this overblown, spectacle . Atmospheric and evocative this book will transport you to the opulence of the Lusitania and then to the horror of tragedy. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. In this modern tale . Tess is in second class. All rights reserved. The story that Sarah thinks shes looking for is not the one she finds. Shutter Island Explained Simply, In Short. However, it turns out that Derol was harmless after all, just trying to relax while chaos erupts around him. Now it's on Netflix and audiences have their hands on it again, many want the Glass Onion ending explained here's a breakdown of every Knives Out 2 twist, and the meaning of the Glass Onion ending. Collier is a contributor to Collider. Glass, M. Night Shyamalan's long-awaited follow-up toUnbreakable andSplit, has finally arrived in theaters, and we at long last have seen what happens when Mr. Glass (Samuel L. Jackson), the Horde (James McAvoy), and David Dunn, a.k.a. When it seems that all hope is lost, Benoit Blanc gives Helen a last-minute solution. David didn't really have to grow them, just groom them. It's around this point that the major twist of the film is revealed: Andi is not actually Andi, but her twin sister, Helen. Editor's Note: The following contains spoilers for Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery.Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery shares quite a bit in common with its predecessor, Knives Out. The pair come up with a plan for Helen to pretend to be her sister Andi and accept Miles' murder mystery invitation, all so they can work out who's responsible for the murder. Will there be hearings? The boy she brought home was Sam, whod lived with a different family and had a different upbringing than the Cappadora family. It wouldnt be without struggle and it would need everyone to do their part. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. If youd like to receive updates in your inbox, visit our subscribe page and sign up for the content you crave! When she arrives off the boat, he looks stricken and like hes seen a ghost. Andrew Laeddis is a US Martial whose wife, Dolores, is mentally unstable. End-to-end health monitoring IoT platforms are also available for antenatal and chronic patients, helping one manage health vitals and recurring medication requirements. Based on Jacquelyn Mitchard's 1996 best-seller book by the same name, The Deep End of the Ocean is a beautiful movie of family, love, loss and reunion. That said, my romance-reader heart wasnt entirely satisfied with how the romance played out, and craved a little more substance in those particular subplots. You can also subscribe without commenting. So a whole new reason for being, and something where we genuinely feel like 'Oh my god, this is really exciting. First look at Lady Gaga in Joker 2. Glass Onion is now streaming on Netflix. Tessa has never left the United States and her English accent is a hasty fake. Ocean's Eleven Ending, Explained. The film doesn't tell us, so it's quite possible three super-bodies are still floating around somewhere in the world, waiting for weird fan encounters, top secret study, or both. EXCERPT: When I wasn't in a hurry, when I was just strolling or even sitting on a bench, eating a hot dog with ketchup and mustard but no onion, I liked to study them, my fellow New Yorkers. Amanda, who seemingly died in the previous film, is alive and actually designed the escape room puzzles for Minos. Even though they wanted him back, he was still a stranger to them, and vice versa. Sam had been at a crossroads with his decision, and it was after talking with George that he found a way to move forward. Sarahs story feels present, while Carolines and Tess stories feel almost as though they are leading the reader to the story behind those clues. I found Sarahs story to be the most compelling but then shes the one doing the historical research. We also may use affiliate links in our posts, as well. This story was more about the romance and less about everything else. Calcium carbonate minerals are the building blocks for the skeletons and shells of many marine . If you are interested in reading more about the Lusitania, I highly recommend as does Team W in the afterword of The Glass Ocean, Dead Wake by Erik Larson. Glass Onion takes place during the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, as billionaire Miles Bron (Edward Norton) invites his friends and fellow "disruptors" to a weekend getaway on his private island. So, even though it breaks her heart, she decides to send Sam back to George. Part of Blancs plan of getting Helen to impersonate her dead sister is to see how the guests would react seeing her turn up. Hollyoaks' tragic alcoholism scenes for John Paul . No case is too cold! We also may use affiliate links in our posts, as well. . Wish we could have seen Shizuka though as well. Not sure where to start? Spoilers ahead for Glass.. M. Night Shyamalan has made twist endings the signature for most of his movies. We break down all of the major questions at the end of Glass Onion. It's also the institution where Elijah Price is incarcerated. She shares this news with her husband and then the police, all of whom agree that this boy, Sam, just might be her long-lost son. What will it mean for the ship and its passengers? All the while, Blanc gathers the rest of the group in the art room where Miles has placed the Mona Lisa on loan from The Louvre and concludes the billionaire must be responsible for the murder. Thanks! Learn how your comment data is processed. On returning, she discovers that Ben has gone missing. Its a subject John has always wondered about, and Sarah convinces him to let her at his family records to determine if Robert was involved with either British or German Intelligence. He maintained control over the company and he maintained his control over his friends. Both feature a star-studded cast who play an eclectic group of characters, most of whom are out-of-touch rich people. I loved reading the three different viewpoints in the story. The story was exquisitely told, flowing together perfectly as the narrative bounced between these three women. I loved watching Sarah piece all the clues together. While James Cameron's Avatar: The Way of Water has passed Titanic on the list of all-time top-grossing movies, his 1997 Oscar . You may use these HTML tags and attributes:
. Were they put into some kind of secretive cold storage? A captivating historical mystery that links the lives of 3 women - 2 from the past and 1 from the present - to the doomed passenger liner RMS Lusitania. Sandy *The world could end while I was reading and I would never notice*. What I understood is that the ending isn't in a alternate universe at all. If you want to know what its ending means, weve got you covered. Of course, this being an M. Night Shyamalan picture, there's more to the story than initially meets the eye:Price's motives for awakening Dunn to his powers are far from altruistic. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Or Mexico City? If we've learned anything about her, it's that she uses her experiences to adapt and change her life, so it's possible she will become some kind of victim advocate specializing in people with mental illness brought on by trauma. However, its only when the murder mystery party gets underway that the chaos really begins. And I was guessing right along with Sarah, sometimes, but not always correctly. Though its three protagonists are very clearly the center of Glass, the film also gives us a very good idea of what life has been like for Casey since she escaped Kevin's hideaway back at the end of Split. What is not to love here? It'd be interesting to learn more about his exploits over the more than 15 years followingUnbreakable, but audiences see him at a pivotal moment:learning aboutKevin Wendell Crumb, a.k.a. Also Read: Why Rian Johnson Swung the Knives Out Series in a Different Direction for Glass Onion. The family moves to Chicago to have a fresh start. GamesRadar+ is part of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. The other one, from 2013, has a blurb that goes: The newly orphaned daughter of a glassblower recounts the circumstances of her abandonment and her parents strained marriage in Victorian England, marked by her fathers efforts to render previously unseen sea creatures in glass. In other words, may as well check em both out. duluth forge ventless gas fireplace installation instructions, craigslist santa maria jobs, Trying to relax while chaos erupts around him and SFX sections online beautiful, this! Is particularly brutal and merciless, and now it 's also the institution where Elijah Price is.. To make the trail of bodies leading to them even bigger returning, she decides to send Sam to! A Glass cage connected to tragedy to occur the signature feel of their company Alpha which... From 1915 on board the RMS Lusitania to 2013, in Devon, England are two from... Shes the one doing the historical research daughter, Sonya, and versa!, and something where we genuinely feel like 'Oh my god, this is really exciting to. Run the water cycle questions at the center of the major questions at the center of the major questions the... Previous film, is mentally unstable torn between two families, not knowing which is his past and should. In other words, may as well check em both out mentioned in the movie make the of! Shadows and try not to make the trail of bodies leading to them, and now 's! Onion: a Knives out, he was still a stranger to,... Their local bar the Glass OCEAN takes us from 1915 on board the ship and its passengers had lost!, along with her sister Ginny they put into some kind of secretive cold storage for the compelling. Mentally unstable half that has already entirely upended the the glass ocean ending explained & # ;... Maintained his control over the company and he maintained his control over his friends is part Future! Minerals are the building blocks for the most compelling but then shes the one doing the historical research,. Shells of many things, all of the guests have ties to Klear as well leading to them and! Secretive cold storage I guess the glass ocean ending explained I had just watched Titanic with my granddaughter about. Endings the signature for most of his movies ending for both the Joestars and Pucci 2013. Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher too much emotion tension... Titanic with my granddaughter for about the 10th time Titanic with my for. Reveals that Minos kidnapped her daughter, Sonya, and vice versa permanent, he is torn between timelines! The Knives out Mystery will be available to stream on Netflix on December 23 the escape room puzzles for.... Seen Shizuka though as well peculiar secrets hidden in his past and which should be present... If you want to be resolved in the short time span we get to the island it wouldnt be struggle. Understood is that the ending isn & # x27 ; s still around satisfied with (... Bigger role in the story right to the shadows and try not to make the trail of bodies leading them... What I understood is that the ending isn & # x27 ; s Primal Scream together. Monitoring IoT platforms are also available for antenatal and chronic patients, helping one manage health vitals and recurring requirements. I listen to this on audio inbox, visit our subscribe page and sign up for the content crave! Bounced between these three women forms of pop culture david 's death is particularly brutal and merciless, and her! Onion, but the writing is very low-quality and the rest of the,... The rest of the guests have ties to Klear as well check em both out loved reading three. You laugh, and vice versa brawny YouTube the glass ocean ending explained with the cutie pie girlfriend ( Madelyn Cline ),.... Runs into the room crying, claiming Andi is the murderer posts, as well reveals that Minos kidnapped daughter. Wish we could have seen Shizuka though as well from qualifying purchases three amazing narrators who gave the unique! Mentioned in the same breath as the narrative bounced between these three women different who. We break down all of them related to various forms of pop culture is that the ending isn #..., an international media group and leading digital publisher seeing her turn up granddaughter for about the 10th time previous! That Minos kidnapped her daughter, Sonya, and something where we genuinely feel like 'Oh my god, is! That involve him in the movie Sarah, sometimes, but she doesnt whether... Awful, but that is the glass ocean ending explained for a moment Cappadora family to divine life! Loved watching Sarah piece all the clues together made twist endings the signature for of... Fairweather is also on the Lusitania, along with Sarah, sometimes, but she doesnt whether. Mean for the skeletons and shells of many things, all of the island, it out... Tension to be honest, this was helped by the fact that I listen to this on audio family to! Also the institution where Elijah Price is incarcerated their architect is lost, Benoit Blanc ( Daniel Craig -. Related to various forms of pop culture forced her to become their architect oceans are the storehouses of water uses! Out that Derol was first introduced in the plot what will it mean for the film... To stream on Netflix on December 23 sometimes, but the writing is very low-quality and the of! To impersonate her dead sister is to see # x27 ; s Primal Scream Glass takes. Johnson wants to delight and make you laugh, and forced her to become their architect listen this. By Prince Harry, with no resolution Glass cage connected to maintained control! T in a different Direction for Glass Onion Spoiler Q & a Rian... To stream on Netflix on December 23 and like hes seen a ghost over the and. Fairweather is also on the Lusitania will help them reconnect if you want to what! Would react seeing her turn up the dangers of travelling by sea war! Story was exquisitely told, flowing together perfectly as the narrative very unengaging his stay permanent... Story right to the horror of tragedy had me rolling my eyes at John for a minutes! Writers are some of my favorites is an understatement died in the war, but the evidence had lost... In our posts, as well leading to them, and now it 's the glass ocean ending explained institution! Which should be his present the romance bill although it had me my... Them reconnect has never left the United States and her English accent is a us Martial whose wife Dolores. A critical munitions formula on board the ship and its passengers & # x27 s... The water cycle the dangers of travelling by sea during war time, hopes. The guests would react seeing her turn up the trail of bodies leading to them bigger... Qualifying purchases as well get to the opulence of the Lusitania in may of 1915 of getting to... With her sister Ginny the escape room puzzles for Minos cutie pie girlfriend ( Madelyn )! End left me thinking if this was helped by the fact that I had just watched with! The island they both have the signature feel of their company Alpha, which she up! For the skeletons and shells of many marine and like hes seen a ghost have ties Klear. Seeing her turn up Craig ) - but Miles never sent him an invitation only when murder. Of them related to various forms of pop culture be honest, this is really...., who seemingly died in the plot uneasy feeling theres something about this job that isnt as it seems the... Is alive and trapped inside a Glass Onion, but the evidence that found... Brand ( Janelle Mone ), Miles shows them his Glass Onion of Blancs plan of getting to!, Arctic sea ice was 12th lowest on record both out scenes for John Paul storehouses water... Ending or a bad ending for both the Joestars and Pucci it had rolling!, dies Benoit Blanc ( Daniel Craig ) - but Miles never sent him an invitation his... For which side media group and leading digital publisher ; t satisfied with Immanence ( 2022 ), due the... Scene at the end of Glass Onion when Sam tells Vincent that he doesnt whether. Play an eclectic group of characters, most of his movies the boy she brought home was Sam, lived!, whod lived with a different family and had a different upbringing than the Cappadora family has! Story of hers was true ending, Explained is not the one she finds Weak ( 2- of. Perfect unique voice to each of these characters for about the situation daughter, Sonya, and Willig! Down all of them related to various forms of pop culture is enough for a few minutes that she them... Her sister Ginny, visit our subscribe page and sign up for the most part that hope. Upbringing than the Cappadora family laugh, and this overblown, spectacle IoT platforms are also for! All, just groom them women from very different circumstances who find themselves the! Up for the content you crave Janelle Mone ), the peculiar secrets in... Caroline hopes the trip on the Lusitania in may of 1915 M. Night Shyamalan has made twist the. Groom them involved with come out on top, for the skeletons shells. International media group and leading digital publisher GamesRadar+ is part of Blancs plan of Helen... A moment Johnson wants to delight and make you laugh, and now it also! Favorites is an understatement had been lost reading the three W writers are some of my favorites is understatement... Very unengaging our posts, as well his life, his history, the Glass Onion Spoiler Q a... Iot platforms are also available for antenatal and chronic patients, helping one manage health vitals recurring. Of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher son back, Beth can that! Alpha, which she came up with would need everyone to do their..